Title:
Field Testing to Failure of a Skewed Solid Concrete Slab Bridge
Author(s):
Fabien Lagier, Bruno Massicotte, David Conciatori, Jean-François Laflamme
Publication:
Symposium Paper
Volume:
342
Issue:
Appears on pages(s):
40-59
Keywords:
solid slab bridges, field testing, load rating, shear failure, nonlinear finite element analysis
DOI:
10.14359/51725936
Date:
6/1/2020
Abstract:
In 2006 in Quebec, a skewed cantilever solid concrete slab bridge without shear reinforcement collapsed due to a shear failure, which highlighted the need to improve the assessment of this type of structure. A large experimental program was carried out to test three decommissioned solid slab bridges to failure. In parallel, an
extensive nonlinear finite element analysis study was performed with the aim of better understanding the failure mechanisms, the degree of load redistribution, and to gain insight into the ultimate shear capacity of these structures. A beam shear failure mode was expected for the first two bridge tests, but a flexural failure mode was observed. This paper focusses mainly on the last field test of a simply supported solid slab bridge having a 40 degree skew. The load
position and the loading protocol were established with the objective of causing a shear failure at the obtuse corner of the slab where high shear forces develop. The main test motivation was to illustrate that simply supported solid slab bridges would normally not be prone to shear failure due to an intrinsic redundancy. The paper presents experimental techniques that could help bridge owners in assessing the performance of their bridges. The test results also provide
valuable information for calibrating nonlinear element models that can be used for assessing the carrying capacity of existing concrete bridges. Although the actual bridge conditions were worse than anticipated, a global shear failure mode occurred near the
obtuse corner at a maximum load of 1400 kN, which significantly exceeded the factored shear force due to the maximum traffic load. The failure was followed by a gradual load redistribution toward undamaged portions of the slab. This field test confirmed the assumption of non-fragility for this type of bridge, where support conditions enable development of an intrinsic redundancy. Despite these observations, nonlinear analyses carried out in parallel to the
testing program indicated that this beneficial effect diminishes with an increase of slab thickness.
Related References:
1. CSA 2014. "Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code – CAN/CSA-S6-14". Canadian Standard Association, Toronto, Ontario.
2. AASHTO 2014. LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, Customary U.S. Units. 7th Edition. Washington DC, USA.
3. Johnson, P.-M, Couture, A. and Nicolet, R. 2007. "Report of Commission of Inquiry into the Collapse of a Portion of the de la Concorde Overpass." Gouvernement du Québec.
4. Massicotte, B., Ben Ftima, M., Conciatori, D. 2015. "Development of a Bridge Evaluation Method using Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis – Application to Existing Structures", Report SR14-03, Group for Research in Structural Engineering, Polytechnique Montreal, 133p. In French.
5. Lantsoght, E.O.L. 2013. Shear in reinforced concrete slabs under a concentrated load close to the support. Ph.D. Thesis, Delft University of Technology.
6. Vaz Rodrigues, R, Ruiz Fernandez, M, Muttoni, A. 2008. Shear strength of R/C cantilever slabs. Engineering Structures, 30, 3024-3033.
7. Théoret, P., Massicotte B. and Conciatori, D. 2012. Analysis and Design of Straight and Skewed Slab Bridges. ASCE Journal of Bridge Engineering. 17 (2), 289-301.
8. Massicotte, B., Cossette, G., Yildiz, E., BenFtima, M., Rochon-Massicotte, G., Conciatori, D. 2011. "Study on the behavior of a solid slab without shear reinforcement during a field test". Report SR09-02, Group for Research in Structural Engineering, Polytechnique Montreal, 118p. In French.
9. Massicotte, B., Conciatori, D. 2012. "Study on the behavior of a solid slab without shear reinforcement during a field test", Report SR11-01, Group for Research in Structural Engineering, Polytechnique Montreal, 108 p. In French.
10. AASHTO 2018. Manual for Bridge Evaluation – 3rd Edition. Washington DC, USA.
11. Morrison, D. G. and Weich, G. R. (1987). "Free-edge and obtuse-corner shear in R/C skew bridge decks." ACI Structural. J., 84(1), 3–9.
12. Jorgenson, J. L., and Larson, W. 1976 "Field testing of a reinforced concrete highway bridge to collapse." Transportation Research Record 607, 66-71.
13. Azizinamini. A., Boothby, T.E., Shekar, Y., Barnhill, G. 1994 "Old concrete slab bridges. I: Experimental investigation." Journal of Structural Engineering. ASCE, 120 (11): 3284-3304.
14. Miller, R. A., Aktan, A. E. and Shahrooz, B. M. 1994 "Destructive testing of decommissioned concrete slab bridge." Journal of Structural Engineering 120 (7), 2176-2198.
15. Pressley, J.S., Candy, C.C., Walton, B, L,, Sanjayan, J.G.. "Destructive load testing of Bridge No. 1049-analyses,
predictions and testing." In Fifth Austroads Bridge Engineering Conference–Hobart, May 1.
16. Massicotte, B., Lagier, F. 2017. "Study on the behavior of a solid slab without shear reinforcement during a field
test", Report SR16-01, Group for Research in Structural Engineering, Polytechnique Montreal, 118 p. In French.
17. Massicotte, B., and Ben Ftima, M. 2015. “EPM3D-v3.4 – A user-supplied constitutive model for the nonlinear finite element analysis of reinforced concrete structures’, Report SR15-08. Group for Research in Structural Engineering, Polytechnique Montréal, Montreal.
18. Hibbitt, H. D., Karlson, B. I. and Sorensen, E. P. 2014. ABAQUS version 6.14, finite element program, Hibbitt,
Karlson and Sorensen, Providence, R.I.
19. Massicotte, B., Yildiz, E., Conciatori, D. 2012. "Study on the effects of backfill on the strength of solid slab
bridges", Report SR12-08, Group for Research in Structural Engineering, Polytechnique Montréal, Montreal, 54 p. In French.
20. Matlab 2016. The Mathworks, Inc., Natick, Massachusetts, United States